Gluten-Free Soy Sauce Substitutes: Tamari, Coconut Aminos & What Actually Works

Most people are surprised the first time they read a soy sauce label. Soy sauce is traditionally brewed with roughly equal parts soybeans and wheat, which makes the standard bottle in almost every kitchen off-limits for celiacs.

The good news is that the substitutes are genuinely good — several are indistinguishable in a finished dish. Here is what each one is and when to reach for it.

Why regular soy sauce contains wheat

Wheat is not a filler here; it is part of the traditional brewing process. It feeds the fermentation and contributes the slightly sweet, rounded flavour that separates soy sauce from plain salt water.

That means you cannot rely on a soy sauce being safe simply because it is a premium or imported brand. If anything, traditionally brewed sauces are more likely to contain wheat, not less.

The fermentation does break down some gluten, but not reliably enough to make regular soy sauce safe for coeliacs. Do not treat "fermented" as "gluten-free".

Tamari — the closest match

Tamari is a Japanese soy sauce made with little or no wheat. It is the substitute most cooks settle on, because it behaves exactly like soy sauce in a pan and tastes slightly richer and less sharp.

The important caveat: tamari is not automatically gluten-free. Some tamari is brewed with a small amount of wheat. The bottle needs to say gluten-free, and ideally carry a certification mark.

Use it anywhere you would use soy sauce, at the same quantity. Stir-fries, marinades, dipping sauces, fried rice — no adjustment needed.

Coconut aminos — sweeter, soy-free too

Made from fermented coconut palm sap, coconut aminos contain no soy, no wheat and no gluten. They are noticeably sweeter and milder than soy sauce, and considerably lower in sodium.

That sweetness matters in cooking. In a dish that already has honey, mirin or sugar, coconut aminos can tip it over. A useful rule: start with the same amount, then adjust the salt separately, since you are losing a lot of it in the swap.

Best for: dressings, glazes, anything where a little sweetness is welcome. Less ideal for a salty dipping sauce.

Shop gluten-free sauce on Amazon

Certified options with current prices — skip the label-squinting

Gluten-free sauce worth trying

⭐ Best Seller

San-J Organic Tamari

Brewed GF soy sauce alternative

Check Price on Amazon

$14.99Price as of Aug 23

Primal Kitchen Sauces

All-natural, GF sauces & dressings

Check Price on Amazon

$4.77Price as of Aug 23

Kikkoman GF Soy Sauce

Trusted brand, certified GF

Check Price on Amazon

$8.69Price as of Aug 23

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices and availability are captured periodically and may change — the price shown on Amazon at checkout applies.

Liquid aminos — check the source

Liquid aminos are made from soybeans, usually without fermentation. Some are labelled gluten-free and some are not, and the category name alone tells you nothing.

The flavour sits between tamari and coconut aminos: savoury, quite salty, slightly different in a way most people stop noticing after a week.

As with everything in this list, the label decides.

Making your own in a pinch

If you are mid-recipe with nothing suitable in the cupboard, this gets you surprisingly close:

Simmer for a couple of minutes to reduce slightly. It will not fool a purist, but in a stir-fry with garlic and ginger it disappears completely.

The sauces that catch people out

Soy sauce is rarely the only risk in an Asian-inspired dish. These commonly contain wheat or are built on soy sauce:

Each of these has gluten-free versions available. None of them is safe by default.

Eating out with this in mind

At a restaurant, "we can make it without soy sauce" is not the same as "we can make it gluten-free". The wok, the shared oil, and the sauce already on the noodles all matter.

The useful question is not "is there soy sauce in it" but "what sauce do you use, and is it made with wheat" — followed by whether the dish is cooked on shared equipment.

The short version

Tamari for accuracy, coconut aminos for a sweeter and soy-free option, liquid aminos as a middle ground. All three need the label checked, because the category name is a description, not a guarantee.